Vice demonizes beloved author in piece that totally disregards the facts

December 16, 2021

By Tim Worstall

J.K. Rowling is fomenting trans hatred, she’s describing the law in Scotland, the country she lives in. This apparently is something that Vice isn’t capable of understanding.

The magazine says that in a piece headlined, “J.K. Rowling Just Won’t Stop Attacking Trans People Online,” which also states that “[t]he comment is only the latest in a string of efforts by the once-beloved author to amplify a narrative that’s not only essentially false but also ignores the devastatingly high level of violence experienced by trans people.”

This is all in reaction to this tweet sent:


Or the lines: “War is Peace. Freedom is Slavery. Ignorance is Strength,” Rowling tweeted. “The Penised Individual Who Raped You Is a Woman.” “

The background to that is that the Scottish police force has declared that the gender of those charged with a crime will be recorded as the self-declared gender. We might think this is just fine, except Scottish law (which is different from English) states that rape is a crime that can only be committed with a penis. So, it is possible that a transwoman could be charged with rape and recorded as a woman in the crime statistics – for a crime that one must physically make to commit. 

This is what Rowling is talking about, not any hatred of anyone trans nor ignoring any level of violence that might be directed at them. 

It is also true that self-declaration is to be taken as the definition for those found guilty and sent into the prison estate. So, a penised rapist who self-declares as female would be sent into the women’s prison. This has actually happened in England, the country next door, where the rapist promptly – allegedly, the case has not been tried yet – assaulted at least one other woman inmate. 

This is not hatred nor ignorance of violence. It’s pursuing what seems the obviously correct line of inquiry. We do indeed all want people to be their own true selves. The difference between male and female – as PJ O’Rourke once pointed out – doesn’t matter most of the time, like when trading bonds, matters enormously at others, like when making babies. The trick is to know when this matters and what should be done about it when it does.

Vice really needs to grasp – so that it can inform its readership – that concerns about the margins of trans definitions is not the same as hatred towards those trans. Noting that women can now be convicted of rape in Scotland, a crime that requires the use of a penis, is not ignoring anti-trans violence. It is, in fact, a sensible query over when self-declaration is, or is not, sufficient as the definition of a woman.


Accuracy in Media uses investigative journalism and citizen activism to expose media bias, corruption and public policy failings. Progressives and their allies in the newsroom have a stronghold over the mainstream media in this country, but they aren’t stopping there.

They are targeting our education system, Big Tech, the entertainment industry — every facet of America’s culture.

To fight back against the overbearing control they have of our society, you and I must take action now.
Join us in this fight by taking the pledge below and signing your name.

  • I pledge to do my part in holding journalists accountable.
  • I pledge to support freedom of speech whenever views are silenced.
  • I pledge to uphold the values of a well-informed free society.

Pledge Now

Your Name:(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.