Salon calls uses Dem report as unbiased source

January 13, 2022

By Tim Worstall

Salon agrees with a report from Congressional Democrats, no harm in that. But to agree with such a report is not the same as that report “debunks” criticism of it. To debunk is to disprove, to show to be wrong. And, despite the best attempts of Salon, for politicians to support their own policy is not to disprove, or show to be wrong, criticisms of that policy.

But this is what they claim: “Report debunks Joe Manchin’s inflation argument against Build Back Better.”

Manchin, a Democratic senator from West Virginia, has been saying that he thinks that Build Back Better will, by increasing government spending and possibly the deficit thereby increase inflation – which has just been recorded at 7% so that is a concern. Salon refers to a report that says this is not so. There’s a slight mistake at Salon on even this: “But a new report published Wednesday by the Congressional Joint Economic Committee argues that Democrats’ 10-year, $1.75 trillion reconciliation package would actually relieve inflationary pressures on the economy.” But it’s actually from the Democrats on the JEC. So it’s not exactly, and precisely, an independent evaluation of the BBB plans. It’s the people who support the policy saying they support the policy.

It is possible to argue this either way, but the merit of Build Back Better (or even the balanced budget multiplier effect upon inflation) isn’t our point. Manchin might be right — all the Ds on the JEC might be, for the purposes of our argument.

This report does not “debunk” Manchin because it does not disprove his argument at all, it simply restates the well-known political position of other Senate Democrats. It is clear and obvious that Salon agrees with the non-Manchin Ds here as well but that’s still not a disproof.

Agreement and disagreement just are not debunking.

Salon is a major progressive media source. It gains near 9 million visits a month with near 80% of that from the U.S. alone, making it influential in the political scene well beyond that audience.

An assertion from a group of politicians that their plans are just excellent really is not a debunking of a criticism of their plan. It’s politics, which is fine in its place. But journalism is meant to be a speaking of truth to such power, right, not merely an agreement with it?


Accuracy in Media uses investigative journalism and citizen activism to expose media bias, corruption and public policy failings. Progressives and their allies in the newsroom have a stronghold over the mainstream media in this country, but they aren’t stopping there.

They are targeting our education system, Big Tech, the entertainment industry — every facet of America’s culture.

To fight back against the overbearing control they have of our society, you and I must take action now.
Join us in this fight by taking the pledge below and signing your name.

  • I pledge to do my part in holding journalists accountable.
  • I pledge to support freedom of speech whenever views are silenced.
  • I pledge to uphold the values of a well-informed free society.

Pledge Now

Your Name:(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.